Why One-Upmanship Is Hurting Your Professional Relationships and Job Search
Have You Been One-Upping Without Realizing It?
Imagine this: You’re in a networking conversation, and someone shares their recent job interview experience. Before they even finish, you jump in—“Oh yeah, I had a similar interview, but mine was even tougher! They grilled me for an hour straight.” Or perhaps a colleague mentions they’ve taken on a new leadership role, and you instinctively respond, “Oh, I was leading a project like that last year, and it was twice the size.”
Sound familiar?
This is one-upmanship in action, and if you’ve been doing it for years, you might not even notice the harm it’s causing to your career and professional relationships. While it might seem like harmless banter or an attempt to connect, one-upmanship can backfire, leaving you isolated, untrustworthy, and overlooked for opportunities.
The Psychology Behind One-Upmanship
At its core, one-upmanship is driven by deep-seated insecurities. It’s an unconscious way of seeking validation and proving self-worth through comparison. Instead of celebrating someone else’s success or experience, the impulse to “top” their story is a defense mechanism.
People who engage in one-upmanship often:
Feel an intense need to be seen as successful or knowledgeable.
Fear being overshadowed or overlooked.
Struggle with self-esteem and rely on external affirmation.
Have difficulty listening actively because they’re preoccupied with proving themselves.
While this behavior might seem like friendly competition or storytelling, it can alienate colleagues, hiring managers, and professional connections. Over time, it damages credibility and trust, making it harder to form meaningful, mutually beneficial relationships.
One-Upmanship Goes Beyond Conversations
One-upmanship isn’t just about verbal exchanges—it can show up in your work habits and interactions with colleagues. If you constantly feel the need to outperform others to prove your worth, it can create tension in team environments. Managers and interviewers, particularly those who have experienced disruptive team members in the past, may recognize these behaviors as red flags and strive to avoid hiring individuals who exhibit them.
Behaviors that reflect one-upmanship in the workplace include:
Taking credit for others’ contributions.
Constantly interrupting or dismissing teammates’ ideas in meetings.
Over-explaining tasks to demonstrate superior knowledge.
Competing for attention rather than collaborating for solutions.
Recognizing these tendencies in yourself and shifting to a more team-oriented mindset can improve workplace relationships and make you a more attractive candidate for job opportunities.
How One-Upmanship Sabotages Your Job Search
When looking for a job, your reputation and the way you interact with others matter. Here’s how one-upmanship can work against you:
1. Kills Authentic Connections
Networking is about building relationships, not winning verbal sparring matches. When you constantly shift the conversation back to yourself, you lose the opportunity to connect on a genuine level. People remember how you made them feel—and if you make them feel inferior or dismissed, they won’t be eager to help you.
2. Undermines Trust and Credibility
Hiring managers and recruiters are drawn to candidates who demonstrate humility, self-awareness, and collaboration. If you consistently try to outshine others in interviews or professional conversations, you may come across as boastful or insecure rather than competent.
3. Creates Workplace Resentment
If colleagues or hiring decision-makers perceive you as someone who always needs to “win” conversations, they may be less inclined to advocate for you or offer referrals. People want to work with team players, not individuals who make them feel like they’re in a constant competition.
4. Shuts Down Opportunities for Growth
When you engage in one-upmanship, you miss opportunities to learn. Instead of listening and absorbing valuable insights from others, you focus on proving yourself. This can limit your professional development and make you seem uninterested in collaboration.
Healthy Competition vs. One-Upmanship
It’s important to recognize that healthy competition does not require one-upmanship. You can strive for excellence, push yourself to improve, and celebrate achievements without diminishing others. True confidence comes from being secure in your own capabilities, not from coveting the successes of those around you.
Healthy competition:
Encourages growth and motivation without belittling others.
Fosters mutual respect and admiration rather than rivalry.
Builds up individuals and teams instead of creating resentment.
How to Recognize and Stop One-Upmanship
Self-awareness is the first step in overcoming this habit. Here’s how you can check yourself and shift your communication style for better career success:
1. Listen More Than You Speak
Make a conscious effort to pause before responding. Ask yourself: Am I adding value to the conversation, or am I just trying to prove something?
2. Acknowledge Others’ Experiences Without Comparison
Instead of saying, “That happened to me too, but mine was worse,” try: “That’s really interesting! How did you handle that?”
3. Shift from Competition to Collaboration
Instead of viewing conversations as a chance to “win,” use them as a chance to connect. Support and uplift others rather than constantly measuring yourself against them.
4. Develop Confidence That Doesn’t Rely on Comparison
Confidence isn’t about proving you’re better—it’s about knowing your own worth without needing external validation. The more you focus on personal growth, the less you’ll feel the need to engage in one-upmanship.
5. Ask Open-Ended Questions
Show genuine curiosity about others’ experiences rather than waiting for your turn to speak. This makes people feel valued and more likely to engage with you positively.
Build Bridges, Not Barriers
Your professional success isn’t measured by how many times you’ve outdone someone in a conversation. It’s built on trust, authenticity, and meaningful connections.
If you recognize one-upmanship in yourself, it’s never too late to change. By focusing on listening, engaging genuinely, and supporting others, you’ll not only improve your professional relationships but also enhance your reputation as a collaborative and insightful professional.
Want to build stronger connections in your job search? Let’s talk! Reach out for a career consultation, and let’s set you up for success—without the need for one-upmanship.
Comments